Legal Update
November 10, 2026 · Oak Arms Training Group

The Latest Second Circuit Decision in Mills v. New York City

NYS 2nd Circuit Appellate Court

If you’ve been following the ongoing legal battles over gun rights here in New York as closely as I have, you know how frustrating the City’s regulatory maze can be. But we just got some major news: the Second Circuit Court of Appeals issued its decision in Mills v. New York City, and it’s a big deal for every single one of us who carries.

The court didn’t just issue a routine ruling; it called out the lower court for using flawed logic to throw out our challenges to some of the City’s most restrictive rules. Here is my breakdown of what went down, what’s coming next, and why this matters to you.

The Big Wins: Rules Going Back to Court

The lower court judge originally tossed out several of our claims, basically saying these regulations didn’t count as real Second Amendment violations. The Second Circuit stepped in and said, “Not so fast.”

The higher court vacated (canceled) those dismissals, which means our lawyers get to head right back into court to challenge three major restrictions:

The One-Gun Carry Rule: The City says you can only physically carry one registered handgun at a time. The court agreed with us that the Second Amendment explicitly protects the right to bear “Arms” in the plural, not just a single weapon for self-defense.

The 90-Day Waiting Period: Under current rules, you’re forced to wait 90 days between buying handguns. The court recognized that forcing gun owners to wait isn’t just an administrative delay—it’s a deliberate restriction designed to slow down your constitutional rights.

The 2-Gun Permit Limit: City Hall recently scrapped the rule capping carry licenses to two handguns, but the court ruled that plaintiffs can still sue for retrospective damages for the years that rule unconstitutionally limited their options.

Two Major Legal Errors the Court Corrected

What I love about this opinion is that the Second Circuit explicitly fixed two terrible arguments that judges keep using to dismiss gun rights cases:

1. Temporary Bans Are Still Infringements: The court made it crystal clear that the Second Amendment doesn’t only protect against total or permanent gun bans. Partial limits and temporary delays are still infringements under the Constitution.

2. The Government Has to Prove Its Case, Not Us: The court reminded the lower judges that once we prove a rule restricts our ability to keep or carry a firearm, the burden shifts 100% to the government to prove that rule has a deep history in American tradition. We don’t have to prove the law is forbidden; they have to prove it’s allowed.

What Didn’t Stick

To be realistic, we didn’t win every single point. The court kept the dismissal of two areas:

Licensing and Fingerprinting Fees: Relying on older precedent (Kwong v. Bloomberg), the court upheld the City’s ability to charge administrative fees, ruling they aren’t unconstitutional unless we can prove they are completely exorbitant or used abusively.

Procedural Paperwork & Portal Glitches: Claims challenging the specific purchase-authorization forms and backend registration rules were dismissed on technical grounds because the plaintiffs couldn’t establish “Article III Standing”—meaning they couldn’t prove the rule itself directly caused a concrete injury beyond a glitchy website.

What Happens Next?

This isn’t the final finish line, but it’s a huge tactical victory. The case is being sent back down to the district court. Now, under the Bruen standard, New York City is going to have to stand before a judge and produce historical laws from the 1700s and 1800s to justify 90-day waiting periods and one-gun carry limits. Spoiler alert: they’re going to have a very hard time finding them.

I’ll be following this case every step of the way. If you have questions about how these rules affect your current permit or setup, drop a comment below or reach out to me directly.

Train hard, stay legal, and keep fighting for your rights!